|
|
https://www.hwcooling.net/en/lig ... gb-analysis-review/
直接上HW的总结（及翻译）：
ractal Design has done an exceptional job with the illuminated Momentum 12 (RGB) fans. We’ve previously written about the high aerodynamic and cooling efficiency of this new design, with the Momentum 12 fans. That still holds true—only now, ARGB LEDs are added to the list of features of these fans.
Fractal Design 在带有灯光的 Momentum 12 (RGB) 风扇上做得非常出色。我们之前已经写过关于这款新设计的 Momentum 12 风扇在空气动力学和散热效率方面的高表现。这一点依然成立——只不过现在，这些风扇又新增了 ARGB LED 灯效这一特性。
Among RGB-lit fans, the Momentum 12 RGB stands out, as not even in our extensive database are there illuminated fans that consistently rank at the top across different scenarios. RGB fans usually lag behind top-tier non-RGB models, but the Momentum 12 RGB is a clear exception. Its airflow-to-noise ratio is elite, particularly in scenarios that simulate system fan use. In open-air setups, these fans rank in the top five, and in configurations that specifically suppress tonal peaks, they even place second overall—on par with the Noctua NF-A12x25 G2 PWM. That’s clearly an impressive feat.
在带有 RGB 灯效的风扇中，Momentum 12 RGB 脱颖而出，因为即使在我们庞大的数据库中，也没有哪款带灯风扇能在不同场景下始终位居前列。RGB 风扇通常落后于顶级非 RGB 型号，但 Momentum 12 RGB 显然是个例外。它的风量与噪音比堪称顶级，尤其是在模拟系统风扇使用场景下表现突出。在开放式环境中，这些风扇排名前五，而在专门抑制音调峰值的配置中，甚至整体排名第二——与 Noctua NF-A12x25 G2 PWM 并驾齐驱。这无疑是一个令人印象深刻的成就。
With dust filters installed, the Momentum 12 RGB fans drop slightly in relative rankings—particularly when using plastic filters—but their performance remains above average and superior to most competing fans with ARGB lighting. The generational leap from the Aspect 12 RGB PWM is often significant—beneficial for any PC case outfitted with Momentum 12 RGB fans. That, undoubtedly, was one of FD’s goals: to build uncompromising case fans. And among illuminated models, Momentum 12 RGB fulfills that brief entirely. Thanks to LCP (Liquid Crystal Polymer) construction, the impeller blades are exceptionally rigid, leading to exceptionally low vibration.
安装了防尘滤网后，Momentum 12 RGB 风扇的相对排名略有下降——尤其是在使用塑料滤网时——但其性能依然高于平均水平，并优于大多数带有 ARGB 灯效的竞品风扇。与上一代 Aspect 12 RGB PWM 相比，性能提升往往非常显著——这对任何配备 Momentum 12 RGB 风扇的机箱来说都是利好。毫无疑问，这也是 FD 的目标之一：打造毫不妥协的机箱风扇。而在带灯效的风扇中，Momentum 12 RGB 完全实现了这一目标。得益于 LCP（液晶聚合物）材料的应用，风扇叶片极为坚固，带来了极低的振动表现。
Granted, at the upper end of the speed spectrum, vibration does become significant. But at speeds typical for system fans, vibration is negligible. In other words, once regulated to lower or medium RPMs, the Momentum 12 RGB is highly unlikely to be a source of secondary noise (such as through case resonance). It won’t be. These fans also produce highly attractive results when paired with the hexagonal grill.
当然，在高转速区间，振动确实会变得明显。但在系统风扇常用的转速下，振动几乎可以忽略。换句话说，一旦调节到低速或中速，Momentum 12 RGB 极不可能成为次级噪音（如机箱共振）的来源。它不会产生这类问题。这些风扇与六边形风扇网搭配时，也能带来极为出色的视觉效果。
Yes, even in this case (FD Momentum 12 RGB), we must point out somewhat “weaker” performance on radiators. However, it’s important to note that even then, the Momentum 12 RGB outperforms fans like the DeepCool FC120. In fact, it’s difficult to find a more efficient RGB-lit fan for radiator use.
是的，即使在这种情况下（FD Momentum 12 RGB），我们也必须指出其在散热器上的表现略显“逊色”。然而，需要注意的是，即便如此，Momentum 12 RGB 依然优于像 DeepCool FC120 这样的风扇。事实上，很难找到比它在散热器上表现更高效的 RGB 灯效风扇。
We could bring up BeQuiet! Light Wings, for example, but even those fall short of the Momentum 12 RGB. So yes, these new Fractal Design fans are suitable for radiator duty. As system fans, the Momentum 12 RGB is practically unmatched, and on radiators they’re “only” among the elite. That’s across the board—even compared to non-RGB fans. Among illuminated fans, Fractal Design’s Momentum 12 RGB ranks number one in every usage scenario.
我们可以拿 BeQuiet! Light Wings 来举例，但即使是它们也不及 Momentum 12 RGB。因此，这些全新的 Fractal Design 风扇确实适合用于散热器。作为系统风扇，Momentum 12 RGB 几乎无可匹敌，而在散热器上，它们也“仅仅”属于顶级行列。这在各方面都是如此——即使与非 RGB 风扇相比也是如此。在带灯效的风扇中，Fractal Design 的 Momentum 12 RGB 在所有使用场景中都排名第一。
Especially when factoring in the acoustic profile and operating them at medium or lower speeds. Besides a wide RPM range, they also offer low minimum and start-up speeds, and even support semi-passive operation. At low PWM duty cycles, the fan motor stops entirely and the impeller no longer rotates. Simply put, it’s hard to find any valid drawbacks to the FD Momentum 12 RGB fans.
尤其是在考虑到声学特性并以中低速运行时。除了拥有宽广的转速范围外，它们还具备较低的最低转速和启动转速，甚至支持半被动运行。在低 PWM 占空比下，风扇电机会完全停止，叶轮也不再旋转。简而言之，几乎很难找到 Fractal Design Momentum 12 RGB 风扇的任何有效缺点。
Some users might object to the lower brightness of the lighting, but that’s the trade-off for everything else that’s been praised above. If you’re looking for premium RGB fans with no glaring shortcomings, this is it. And what better time to award a top editorial award to RGB fans than now? The “Top-notch” badge is absolutely well-deserved.
有些用户可能会对灯光亮度较低提出异议，但这正是前文所称赞一切优点所需的权衡。如果你正在寻找没有明显短板的高端 RGB 风扇，这就是最佳选择。还有什么比现在更适合为 RGB 风扇颁发顶级编辑奖呢？“顶级”徽章当之无愧。
我个人是用momentum 14 RGB，按照HWcooling的预告，他们也会继续测评14和14RGB。
个人体感来说，作为进风扇又安静又大风
作为冷排扇因为静压不够，噪音就大的多，预定的P14 pro今天刚付了尾款，等到了替换掉冷排上的14 RGB
|
|
310112100042806
发表于 2025-7-1 11:19
